A single 1924-S Buffalo nickel sold for $105,750 at Stack's Bowers in 2016. Most 1924 nickels are worth $4–$75 in circulated grades — but the mint mark and condition can push values into five figures. This free calculator covers all three mint marks, every grade tier, and the key error types.
Check My 1924 Nickel Value →
Select your coin's mint mark, grade, and any known errors, then click Calculate.
Not sure which mint mark, grade, or errors your coin has? There's a free 1924 Nickel Coin Value Checker tool where you can upload a photo and get an AI-powered estimate before using this calculator.
The 1924-S is one of the rarest Buffalo nickels ever struck. Use this visual guide to confirm whether your coin is the key-date San Francisco variety or a more common example.
Want a specific dollar figure, not just a yes/no result?
Run the Free Calculator →Jump to any section:
The three 1924 mint mark varieties form the core of this date's collecting interest, but error coins can multiply any base value significantly. Below are the five most important varieties and error types you need to know, from the common Philadelphia business strike to rare off-center blunders that command premiums regardless of grade.
The 1924-S is the undisputed key date of the three 1924 Buffalo nickel varieties. Struck at the San Francisco Mint, only 1,437,000 pieces entered circulation — the lowest mintage of any 1924 nickel and one of the lowest production figures in the entire Buffalo Nickel series from 1913 to 1938.
To identify it, turn the coin to the reverse and look below the words "FIVE CENTS" for a small letter S. San Francisco coins from this era are notorious for soft, mushy strikes. Examine the bison's horn and upper left leg under a 10× loupe — most 1924-S coins will show flatness here even on technically uncirculated examples.
Collectors pay extraordinary premiums because fewer than three dozen Gem (MS65+) examples are known to exist across both PCGS and NGC populations. Any 1924-S in any grade is genuinely scarce; an MS65 or better coin is a legitimately rare numismatic treasure. The auction record of $105,750, set at Stack's Bowers in November 2016, was achieved by the single finest known PCGS MS66+ example.
The Denver Mint produced 5,258,000 Buffalo nickels in 1924, marked with a D below "FIVE CENTS." While far more available than the 1924-S in lower circulated grades, the 1924-D presents a unique challenge: Denver coins from this mid-1920s period are notorious for their weak, poorly defined strikes resulting from overworked dies pressed beyond their optimal life.
The most diagnostic weak-strike area on the 1924-D is the bison's horn and upper front shoulder. Under a 10× loupe, most examples show incomplete horn definition — a trait so common it became a recognized diagnostic of this date. The Indian's hair braid just above the tie is also frequently soft. A sharply struck 1924-D with full horn detail is genuinely rare and commands a substantial premium above the standard price for its grade.
Despite the strike challenges, well-preserved mint-state 1924-D coins are actively sought by type collectors and date collectors alike. The auction record of $44,063 was achieved by a Heritage Auctions sale of a PCGS MS66 example in June 2013 — representing a coin with unusually sharp strike quality for the issue.
The Philadelphia Mint produced 21,620,000 Buffalo nickels in 1924 — the most common of the three 1924 varieties. Philadelphia coins carry no mint mark anywhere on the design, as the Philadelphia Mint did not use mint marks on the Buffalo Nickel throughout the series's 1913–1938 run.
Despite its high mintage, the 1924-P is paradoxically one of the rarest Philadelphia Buffalo nickels in Gem condition. PCGS numismatist David Hall specifically called the 1924 the rarest Philadelphia Mint Buffalo nickel from 1919 to 1938 in Gem grades. The coin is usually well struck with a frosty mint luster — a contrast to the weakly struck Denver and San Francisco coins of the same year. Circulated examples are common, but surviving Gem examples (MS65+) are genuinely elusive.
A 1924-P in MS67 is a major rarity that has sold for over $12,000 at auction, and the PCGS auction record for the Philadelphia issue stands at $25,200 for an MS67 example sold at Heritage Auctions in January 2019. Collectors who dismiss the 1924-P as common are overlooking one of the most underrated Gem rarities in the entire Buffalo Nickel series.
Doubled die obverse errors occur at the hub-to-die stage of coin production, when the working die receives two or more impressions from the hub at slightly different rotational angles. On a 1924 Buffalo nickel, this results in a visible doubling effect on the obverse design elements. VarietyVista documents at least two 1924 DDO varieties (DDO-001 with a Class IV doubling and DDO-002 with a Class VI spread), meaning the error was produced at the Philadelphia Mint on more than one working die.
The doubling on 1924 DDOs is most visible on the word LIBERTY and on the date digits when examined under a 5× to 10× loupe. Look for a distinct shelf or shadow step at the base of each letter's serif, or a clear second image slightly offset from the primary design element. Machine doubling — a common post-mint distortion — creates a shelf-like smear rather than a distinct second image with rounded contours.
Because no 1924 DDO has been officially mass-certified at PCGS or NGC as a major variety (unlike the famous 1955 Lincoln Cent doubled die), values are driven by collector interest in variety coins rather than mainstream registry-set competition. Attributed examples on certified holders or in ANACS holders with DDO designations command premiums of $75–$500 above base coin value depending on grade and how dramatic the doubling appears.
An off-center strike occurs when the planchet (coin blank) is not properly centered within the collar at the moment of striking. The result is a coin where the dies contact only part of the planchet surface, leaving a crescent-shaped area of blank, unstruck metal on the opposite side. Off-center strikes can range from mildly misaligned (5% off-center, barely noticeable) to dramatically misaligned (50%+ off-center, with nearly half the design missing).
To identify an off-center strike on a 1924 nickel, look for a clearly visible blank metal crescent at one edge of the coin that has no design elements whatsoever. The coin's overall circular outline should be complete — if the coin is missing a section of its edge, that is a clipped planchet error, not an off-center strike. The key authentication point is that the remaining design must be sharp and normally struck; distortion at the design edges is expected near the unstruck area.
Off-center Buffalo nickels from the 1920s are genuinely uncommon because quality control at the U.S. Mints was reasonably tight for this denomination. Values depend on the percentage off-center and whether the date remains visible. Collectors prize examples where the date is fully readable despite significant misalignment — a 20–30% off-center 1924 nickel with full date visible in an NGC or PCGS holder can bring $150–$300 from dedicated error coin specialists.
| Mint | Mint Mark | Mintage | Est. Survivors (all grades) | Survival Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia | None | 21,620,000 | ~7,000 | 0.03% |
| Denver | D | 5,258,000 | ~6,000 | 0.11% |
| San Francisco KEY DATE | S | 1,437,000 | ~6,000 | 0.42% |
| Total | 28,315,000 | ~19,000 | ~0.07% | |
Composition specs: 75% copper, 25% nickel · Weight: 5.00 g · Diameter: 21.2 mm · Edge: plain · Designer: James Earle Fraser · Series: Buffalo (Indian Head) Nickel, Type 2 (bison on flat plain) · Years struck: 1913–1938
Survival estimates are based on data reported by CoinValueChecker.com. Note that despite the 1924-S having the lowest mintage, its survival rate is the highest of the three — reflecting that rarer coins were more likely to be saved by collectors. The 1924-P paradoxically has the lowest survival rate because its high mintage led most examples to circulate to destruction.
Think you've found a rare variety or error? Get an instant dollar estimate.
Use the Free Calculator →Type a description of your coin and our analyzer will identify likely variety, condition, and value range.
The values below reflect current collector market prices based on PCGS auction data and dealer price guides. For a thorough illustrated breakdown of each grade and mint mark combination, the complete 1924 Buffalo nickel identification and value guide covers every condition tier with photo examples. Gold row = 1924-S signature variety; orange row = 1924-P hidden Gem rarity.
| Variety | Good (G4–6) | Fine (F12–15) | Circ. (VF–AU) | Unc. (MS60–64) | Gem (MS65+) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1924-P (No Mark) | $4 – $5 | $8 – $9 | $15 – $73 | $100 – $550 | $850 – $25,200+ |
| 1924-D | $13 – $16 | $46 – $64 | $100 – $550 | $640 – $2,500 | $4,000 – $44,063+ |
| 1924-S ✦ KEY DATE | $23 – $36 | $100 – $160 | $500 – $3,220 | $4,140 – $43,700 | $10,000 – $105,750+ |
| DDO (any mint) | Base + $30 | Base + $50 | Base + $75 | Base + $150 | Base + $300+ |
| Off-Center Strike | $50 – $75 | $75 – $125 | $100 – $200 | $150 – $300 | $250 – $500+ |
Gold row = 1924-S key date · Orange row = Off-Center error · Values are ranges based on recent auction results and dealer guides; actual sale prices vary. Consult PCGS Price Guide for point-in-time updates.
📱 CoinHix lets you snap a photo of your 1924 nickel and get an instant value estimate matched against recent market data — a coin identifier and value app.
All lettering readable, LIBERTY and date fully visible, but design details are flat and merging. The bison's outline is complete but horn and shoulder details are essentially gone. Worth $4–$36 depending on mint mark.
Horn tip is partially visible as a worn nub. Indian's hair braid has some separation. LIBERTY is bold and complete. Most lettering sharp. Worth $8–$160 depending on mint — 1924-S Fine is notably valuable.
Only slight wear on the bison's hip and the Indian's cheekbone. Most original mint luster remains in protected areas. Full horn detail usually present. Worth $46–$3,220 for 1924-S in this grade range.
No wear. Full unbroken luster across all surfaces. Strike must show detail in the bison's horn and shoulder and the Indian's hair above the braid. Few or no contact marks visible. Very rare for 1924-S, uncommon for 1924-P.
🔎 CoinHix can cross-check your coin's condition against graded examples in its database, helping you confirm whether that horn flatness is a strike issue or actual wear — a coin identifier and value app.
The best venue for any 1924-S in VF condition or better, or any Gem 1924-P or 1924-D. Heritage's dedicated numismatic audience includes top-tier registry set collectors who pay record prices for key-date Buffalo nickels. Consignment fees apply but the competitive bidding environment typically exceeds dealer offers by 20–40%.
For mid-range coins worth $25–$500, eBay reaches the widest buyer pool. Check recently sold prices for 1924 Buffalo nickels on eBay and major auction platforms to set your listing price. PCGS or NGC certification dramatically increases buyer trust and final sale price for any coin over $100.
Best for worn common-date examples (1924-P and 1924-D in Good to Fine) worth under $50. Shops offer instant payment and no listing hassle. Expect wholesale pricing — roughly 50–70% of retail value — but the convenience and speed can be worth it for lower-value pieces.
A good middle-ground for coins worth $50–$300 where Heritage feels excessive but eBay fees cut too deep. The community is knowledgeable about Buffalo nickels. Clear photos and honest descriptions of strike quality and surface are essential. Payment via PayPal Goods & Services is standard for buyer protection.
Any 1924 nickel you believe is in AU condition or better — and especially any 1924-S in any grade — should be submitted to PCGS or NGC before selling. Certified coins consistently sell for 30–100%+ more than raw (uncertified) examples. A $50 grading fee on a coin that might be a $500+ 1924-S is money well spent. Current PCGS fee schedule starts at around $50 per coin for standard service.
A 1924 Buffalo nickel's value depends on its mint mark and condition. Philadelphia (no mint mark) examples range from about $4 in Good to over $20,000 in top Gem grades. Denver (D) coins run $13 to $11,900. San Francisco (S) examples, the key date, range from about $23 in Good to over $100,000 in Gem Mint State. Most circulated examples you find will be worth $3–$75 depending on wear and mint mark.
The 1924-S Buffalo nickel had the smallest mintage of the three 1924 varieties — just 1,437,000 pieces struck at San Francisco. Most entered heavy circulation immediately, leaving only a few thousand survivors across all grades. High-grade Gem examples (MS65 and above) are extremely rare with only about three dozen known. The auction record stands at $105,750 for a PCGS MS66+ example sold at Stack's Bowers in November 2016.
Turn the coin over to the reverse (bison) side. Look just below the words 'FIVE CENTS' toward the bottom of the coin. A 'D' indicates Denver, an 'S' indicates San Francisco. If there is no letter present, the coin was struck at the Philadelphia Mint. On heavily worn examples the mint mark can be faint, so use a 5× to 10× loupe in good lighting. The mint mark is critical — it is the single most important factor in determining value.
A 1924 Philadelphia (no mint mark) nickel in typical Mint State (MS60–MS63) grades is worth roughly $100–$260. MS64 examples bring around $500–$550, while MS65 Gem coins can reach $850–$1,400. The 1924 Philadelphia is actually considered the rarest Philadelphia Mint Buffalo nickel from 1919 to 1938 in Gem condition, per PCGS. MS67 examples have sold for over $12,000 at auction.
The 1924-D had a mintage of 5,258,000, making it less common than the Philadelphia issue but more available than the 1924-S. In circulated grades it is moderately scarce, worth $13–$550 depending on wear. Denver strikes from this era are notorious for weak strikes, especially on the bison's horn and shoulder. Sharply struck MS65 examples are genuinely difficult to find. The auction record for 1924-D is $44,063 for a PCGS MS66, sold at Heritage Auctions in June 2013.
No errors have been officially certified exclusively for the 1924 date, but several Buffalo Nickel error types can appear on 1924 coins: doubled die obverse (doubling on LIBERTY or the date), off-center strikes (blank crescent of metal opposite the design), clipped planchet (curved or straight missing section), and die clashes (ghost images of the opposite die transferred to the field). Any of these, especially dramatic examples certified by PCGS or NGC, can add significant premium over base value.
The key grading points on a Buffalo nickel are the bison's horn and hip, the Indian's cheekbone, and the hair braid. In Good grade, all lettering is readable but details are flat. Fine shows a partially visible horn. Very Fine has a clear horn but flat high points on the Indian's hair. About Uncirculated retains most luster with just slight wear on the cheek and hip. Full Mint State means no wear and complete, unbroken luster across all surfaces.
Never clean a 1924 Buffalo nickel. Cleaning removes original surface patina and microscopic metal, permanently destroying the coin's numismatic value. Even a light wipe with a cloth can leave hairlines visible under magnification that grading services penalize. A cleaned coin is typically worth 30–70% less than an original-surface example of the same grade. If your coin has heavy dirt, store it in a coin flip and let a professional conservator handle it — PCGS and NGC both offer conservation services.
The combined mintage for all three 1924 Buffalo nickel varieties is approximately 28,315,000 pieces. Philadelphia produced 21,620,000, Denver produced 5,258,000, and San Francisco produced 1,437,000. Despite the large total, survival rates in collectible condition are low — especially for the Philadelphia issue, which has an estimated survival rate of just 0.03% in any grade, compared to 0.42% for the scarcer San Francisco coins.
For coins worth over $500, Heritage Auctions or Stack's Bowers offer the best exposure to serious collectors and often achieve record prices for key-date Buffalo nickels. For mid-range coins ($50–$500), PCGS-certified examples on eBay reach a wide buyer pool. For coins worth under $50, a local coin shop offers convenience. Always get high-grade or key-date examples (especially 1924-S) independently certified by PCGS or NGC before selling to maximize your price.
It takes under 60 seconds — select your mint mark, grade, and any errors.
Use the Free Calculator Now →